, , , , , , , , , , , ,

ArXiv comment since 19 December 2013

As of 19 December 2013, the ArXiv moderators changed again their retraction comment by stating that G. Forst is now a pseudonym. In a private communication, they justified their latest action by writing that: “Neither the original comment or the modified one reflects current arXiv policy. We have altered the comment accordingly.” As such, they did not retract their previous identification of Mr. Forst with Mr. Ciufolini. Instead, they said that they simply changed their policy, although it sounds quite strange after they left their originally posted comment for 5 years and the Ciufolini-related comment for 4 months this year. Moreover, there is nothing in their pages pointing towards such a change in their policies, which do not even treat similar cases at all.